"Order mattered more than the return assumption. Brokerage first kept us in a lower bracket for three years."
Worked example
Estimates only, not advice
Published
January 14, 2026
Topic
Withdrawal order
Plan type
Core
Take a household with $700k in traditional IRAs, $300k in Roth, and $400k in a taxable brokerage. They want about $90k a year after they stop working. Draw order is not a slogan. It is which account funds that spending first.
- Type the three balances and any cost basis you know. Nothing syncs from a bank.
- Save an IRA-first plan and a brokerage-first plan. Keep spending fixed. Change only the order.
- Run a thousand futures on both. Compare estimated federal tax in year one and the survival band later.
- If the gap is noise, stop arguing. If it is material, take both exports to a tax person.
In a sample run typed into Jeme, IRA-first produced roughly $18k more estimated federal tax in year one than brokerage-first, before state tax. That gap is not a guarantee. It is the kind of range difference you want to see before you pick a default order.
Jeme never links a bank or brokerage. Projections are estimates. This is software, not tax advice. Layer a Roth conversion, nudge Social Security claim age, or raise spending by $10k in Core if you want more room than one Free plan.
The point is not a single magic order. It is seeing the tax shape of your own numbers before you commit.




.png)